• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Brother's Pizza Greencastle: Your Local Pizza and Comfort Food Destination

Brother's Pizza Greencastle, located at 50 Pine Dr, is a beloved local gem in PA known for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious menu. With a reputation for exceptional service, guests enjoy speedy delivery and friendly dine-in experiences. The menu features an array of tantalizing options, from thin-crust Hawaiian pizza to succulent sirloin steak salads and crispy onion rings. Patrons rave about the breakfast options, making it a popular spot for all-day dining. As a community staple for years, Brother's Pizza continues to delight customers with its commitment to quality and flavorful dishes, ensuring a memorable meal for everyone.

Brother's Pizza Greencastle at a glance

  • Address 50 Pine Dr, Greencastle, PA 17225, United States
  • Phone +1 717-597-5322
  • Restaurant type Restaurant , Italian restaurant , Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for breakfast , Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Brother's Pizza Greencastle: Reviews & Ratings

Alicia Auman
5

Absolutely loved having Taylor as our delivery driver! She was quick, polite, super fun, and so great!!!!! Food was awesome, and reasonably priced. We have found our pizza spot!

Brett Matak
5

Easy one minute off of I-81, quick sit down meal. Friendly service and good food. Sirloin steak salad with avocado, blue cheese and a side of fries. The onion rings were cooked perfectly and the dipping sauce yummy ! The family loved the subs and said the bread was really good. We will be back.

carole chandler
5

Stopped at Holiday Inn right next door and decided to order from Brother's. Had Hawaiian pizza and wings to go...fabulous! Served piping hot, nice thin crust with just the right amount of pizza sauce and plenty of pineapple. Wings loaded with bbq sauce. Would definitely return.

Cindy Burgener
5

Typically order from delivery; however, we decided to stop in at the restaurant to eat locally... what a surprise! Lots of updates to the interior and menus! Lots of great food selections to choose from!! Definitely recommend the taco salad with beef/ask for extra beet, extra salsa, extra sour cream and don’t forget your cup of jalapeno peppers!! Absolutely delicious! Love the new digital sign out front as well!

Ariel
5

I love this place. I’ve been coming since I was a child. My family would sit at the old location in the booth and watch the 90s tv in the corner. When I was in my early 20s, we would always order delivery. I’ve always been a breakfast fan as well. Whenever my pappy was alive we would come down and get breakfast a lot. I was devastated when they stopped serving breakfast at one point and now that breakfast is back I’m so happy. You won’t find a better breakfast in town and you won’t find a better pizza in town. A local community staple for many years. Happy to be a customer and happy for the service!

Tim Fields
5

Absolutely fantastic experience at Brother's Pizza in Greencastle! We tried the Eggplant Parmesan, Cheesesteak, and wings — and every bite was excellent. The Eggplant Parmesan was perfectly cooked with a rich, flavorful sauce, the Cheesesteak was packed with tender meat and melty cheese, and the wings were crispy, juicy, and full of flavor. What made our visit even better was our server, Lexi. She was spot on the entire time — friendly, attentive, and an absolute joy to work with. She made us feel welcome and taken care of from start to finish. Highly recommend this spot for delicious food and top-notch service. We’ll definitely be back!

J c
5

Best fajita ever !!! Me and my wife really enjoyed this place , friendly staff great service we definitely will be back !! Great job guys keep the hard work!!!

Matt Saez
5

Found this place bc it was the closest place to eat and gotta say it has been great. I love their cheese steaks one of the best I have had. The curly fries were great and so were the loaded fries. I'm sure I'll try different things it's just hard for me not to order the cheese steak

Location

  • Brother's Pizza Greencastle
    Brother's Pizza Greencastle
    50 Pine Dr, Greencastle, PA 17225, United States Hotline: +1 717-597-5322

Welcome to Brother's Pizza Greencastle, a beloved culinary haven nestled at 50 Pine Drive in Greencastle, PA. With a legacy that has woven itself into the fabric of the community, this charming eatery stands as a stronghold for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. Whether you're a longtime patron or a newcomer, the moment you step through the doors, you're greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that promises an exceptional dining experience.

What sets Brother's Pizza apart is not just its delicious offerings, but the remarkable commitment to quality and service. Customers rave about the quick, friendly service provided by staff like Taylor, who ensure that every dining experience is enjoyable, whether you're indulging in a mouthwatering pizza or enjoying a hearty salad. The sirloin steak salad, with perfectly cooked onion rings and fresh ingredients, showcases the attention to detail in every dish. As one satisfied customer notes, “The family loved the subs, and said the bread was really good.”

Let's talk pizza. Locals can't get enough of the Hawaiian pizza, renowned for its thin crust and balanced flavors of rich BBQ wings piled high with sauce. Another patron reminisced about delightful family dinners spent over delicious pies and fond memories made over slices. One customer even celebrated the return of breakfast, declaring it the best in town, jointly highlighting Brother's Pizza as a place to relive treasured moments and create new ones—whether for a casual meal or a warm family gathering.

The recent interior updates and new menu selections breathe fresh life into the dining experience, making it a must-see for both locals and travelers. With its easy access just off I-81, Brother's Pizza offers an inviting stop for those on the road in search of quality, flavorful cuisine. The unique taco salad, another customer favorite, is a reminder that there's something for everyone here, making it a versatile destination.

In a world where fast food dominates, Brother's Pizza Greencastle remains a charming reminder of what a true local pizzeria should embody—community, flavor, and heart. So, grab your friends or family, or perhaps just treat yourself, and experience the culinary delights that have kept customers coming back for years. With its delectable selection and commitment to excellence, you might just find your new favorite pizza spot.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
    • Does not have assistive hearing loop
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards